“We don’t realize that we as individual human beings on this planet have the power.”
Every year of her youth in Lakeville, Connecticut, Dr. Alexandra Morton watched The Wizard of Oz with her four siblings. Every time, she was terrified, watching as Dorothy went through so many struggles. But at the end, there was always relief. Dorothy realized she had possessed the power to fix her problem every step of the way; all she had to do was click those slippers…
Now, as a biologist living in Echo Bay, British Columbia, Alexandra (Alex) sees The Wizard of Oz as a keen parallel to our current situation with local salmon farming practices that appear to be depleting sockeye in the Fraser River and serving as a breeding ground for lice, viruses and bacteria in our waters. “The Wizard of Oz is really poignant, because although we’ve been going down a destructive path, biologists have enormous knowledge of how our planet works and can provide alternatives to farming,” she says. “We have the power to put those alternatives into effect.”
For example, getting fish farms out of the ocean and introducing hydroponic alternatives that don’t interfere with wildlife and make better use of the ocean protein that feeds farm salmon. “Wild salmon have proven to be resilient,” says Alex. “We should find ways of working within their natural habits to figure out how we can bring them back to abundance, while safely farming fish without altering the wild salmon. The sooner we start working with these natural systems, the better.”
A Canadian citizen since 1997, Alex has spent nearly 30 years in coastal B.C., raising her children, studying killer whales and doing her utmost to protect the area from salmon farming. She has devoted herself to the region’s ecosystem, and was fittingly dubbed “the Jane Goodall of Canada’s west coast” by Kickass Canadian Jay Peachy, who recommended her to me. After receiving Jay’s glowing referral, I arranged to speak with Alex. She was hesitant at first to take time from her research, but it was only a matter of minutes before she opened up about the mystical animals who brought her where she is today: home.
Alex came upon her work with salmon because she wanted to study non-human animal communication. Left with a choice between primates and cetaceans, she chose the water bound creatures because she never felt that she fit in with primates, including her own species. “I liked snakes and frogs and stuff like that,” she says. “Even as a teenage girl, I always felt drawn to the natural world (and away from people).”
While studying biology at American University, she came across Dr. John Lilly, who was trying to teach dolphins to speak English. Alex spent two years assisting John and learning the ropes of working with cetaceans and audio equipment. After graduating from American University in 1978, she moved to Los Angeles with the thought preparing for a PhD at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA). But her work at the local oceanarium Marineland of the Pacific took her off course and eventually led her to Canada (where she was ultimately awarded an honourary PhD in 2010 from Simon Fraser University for her research on sea lice).
During her time at Marineland, a remarkable event took place: the first birth of a killer whale conceived in captivity. At the staff’s request, Alex moved her sound equipment into the whale tank and “immediately fell in love with the sounds and the animals themselves.” After having struggled through the dolphins’ high speed, high frequency chatter, the slow, deep sound of the whales, who communicated in her hearing range, was music to her ears. She promptly changed her course of study to killer whales.
Over the next two years, Alex was blown away but what she witnessed. The whales demonstrated incredibly sophisticated and poetic behaviour. “They had a ceremony they would do when the light first hit they tank,” she says. “They had very complex relationships and made beautiful, beautiful sounds, and I was starting to get the pattern of them. They had ways they would start their conversation and ways they would sign off. I could tell when they were excited.”
She could also tell that studying them in captivity wasn’t something she could bear. The killer whale calf had died within weeks because its mother, captured at five years of age, never learned know how to feed her offspring. When a second calf was born, it met with the same fate. But this time, Alex had a firsthand account of the entire ordeal. She was devastated to watch “in horror” as the whales she’d grown to know and love went through the heartbreaking experience.
“The staff at the oceanarium were wonderful; they were doing absolutely everything they could think of,” she says. “But a whale captured at five years just doesn’t have the ability to nurse its child. She clearly cared about her calf… but it’s complicated with a cetacean; in nature, another female pushes the baby down to show it how to nurse.”
In 1979, Alex decided to look for ways to apply her knowledge to a study in the wild. She knew that every family of whales spoke a unique dialect. Having grown accustomed to the language of the whales at Marineland, Alex dreamed of finding their family and studying them in their natural habitat. It turned out to be easier than she imagined.
Into the wild
As luck would have it, Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO) was conducting whale research on B.C.’s west coast at the time. Alex reached out to Dr. Michael Bigg, a DFO researcher who had been tasked with counting the number of whales in the area. In photographing the animals, he’d noticed distinctions on each of the whales that allowed him to count them individually, enabling him to identify the mothers of the captive killer whales from their capture photos. Happy to help Alex in her quest, he sent her the images and recommended that she visit Alert Bay, B.C. in August.
Needing no further encouragement, Alex and two friends made a beeline for Alert Bay with an old inflatable boat. As they waited at the dock, the very killer whales Alex was seeking swam up. “I dropped my hydrophones overboard and instantly heard the same calls as the ones made by the whales in captivity,” she says. “But now these calls were just rolling on and on through the mountainous landscape under the sea. It was pretty wonderful.”
In that moment, Alex knew she’d found not only the whales’ true home, but also her own. “I took one sniff of the area and thought, ‘Okay, this is definitely my habitat,’” she says. “I liked the cold and I liked the wet and I liked everything.”
She quickly made plans to spend a year in Canada. In 1980, she returned to Alert Bay, where she found the whales and something else that made its way into her heart just as quickly: her future husband Robin Morton. Robin, “a very cute Canadian filmmaker,” was filming the whales and needed a scientist to interview. They soon began collaborating on and off water, and “I was married, pregnant and living on a boat within a year,” says Alex.
Once it was clear that Alex’s stay in Canada was permanent, she and Robin began searching for a place from which to conduct a long-term study on whales. They travelled the coast, documenting the cetaceans and earning money through charters, all the while seeking out a new home. “We needed a place where whales were in protected waters so we could work all winter, we needed a school of some sort for our son, who was just an infant, and we wanted some form of communication with the outside world,” says Alex.
In October 1984, a pod of whales led the Mortons home. They followed the animals into a cluster of islands called the Broughton Archipelago in Echo Bay, and discovered that it offered everything they needed: wilderness, protected waters, a one-room school, a post office and whales. The family of three fit right in with their boat; almost everyone in the tiny community lived on floating homes.
The Mortons enjoyed a few short years together before their fortune took a sad turn. In the summer of 1986, Robin drowned filming whales. Then, in 1987, the first salmon farm showed up in Echo Bay.
It was the older fishermen in the area who were the first to wave warning flags. “They were saying to me, ‘They’re putting them all in the wrong places… They’re putting them exactly where the salmon like to hold,’” says Alex. As the only person in Echo Bay with a word processor, she agreed to write a letter to DFO on the fishermen’s behalf. Over the next 10 years, as the concerns and evident problems associated with the salmon farms grew, she went on to send 10,000 pages of letters.
“I was convinced for a long time that if I just lined up my words in the right order, (the government) would understand that there was a problem here on a lot of levels, but that it was solvable,” says Alex. The problems ranged from displaced whales—who listened once to the loud sounds played to keep seals away from the farms and never returned—to toxic algae blooms and rampant disease.
In response to her letters, the government repeatedly stated that there was “no evidence” of the problems she reported. So when sea lice became an issue in 2001, Alex didn’t bother appealing to DFO. Instead, she took it upon herself to do the research and provide the evidence. With the help of experts in Norway and Scotland, she studied up on the life stages of the lice and quickly became quite an expert herself; her work on the impact of farm lice on wild salmon has been published worldwide.
With solid research behind her, as well as several environmental organizations, Alex was able to mandate the salmon farmers to change their practices to reduce the lice population. This protected “perhaps a billion young wild salmon” from being eaten by lice. But she wasn’t able to move the farms away from the wild salmon migration routes, because the farmers argued that by using “quite a toxic drug” on farmed salmon, it would protect wild fish from the lice.
This logic, Alex says, is a fallacy. “Trying to get away with breaking the natural laws by putting a feed lot in the ocean isn’t going to work. The pathogens will always take advantage of this kind of feedlot situation, and while the farm fish are getting drugged to prevent them from dying, wild fish get no protection and die. Meanwhile, sea lice become resistant to the drugs, so larger quantities of more toxic chemicals are required for the farm fish. It’s a losing battle, and one we’ve lost with every parasite we have attempted to control with drugs.”
She explains that adult wild Pacific salmon die in the river after they spawn. The common rationale among scientists is that this behaviour breaks the cycle of disease; when the parents die, so do most of the diseases they carry, leaving the youngsters free to swim to sea with the majority of pathogens gone. But the farms hold salmon on the migration route, so when the adults come home, they spread lice, viruses and bacteria to farm salmon, which breed these pathogens all winter and then infect the new crop of salmon in the spring at extremely high levels.
“Every natural, wild, healthy population is carrying around the seeds of its destruction,” says Alex. “There’s always viruses, parasites and bacteria at a very low level. In this way, if an organism gets out of control, nature’s got the off switch already built in. Nature will not allow a whole bunch of salmon in one place. But the farms prevent the natural off switch from playing its role. That is the fundamental problem with salmon farming: it breaks the natural laws that hold disease in checks and balance.”
Farmed and dangerous
After feeling helpless for too long, Alex describes “a really wonderful coming together” of herself and a number of environmental organizations in 2001, including the David Suzuki Foundation and Living Oceans Society. Together, they formed the Coastal Alliance for Aquaculture Reform (CAAR), with a mission to “protect wild salmon, coastal ecosystems, coastal communities and human health from destructive fish farming practices.” But although there were talks with government and industry, Alex came away with the strong impression that they were dealing with “master corporate negotiators,” and that she was still going to have to do a lot of her own legwork to make any headway in reforming salmon farming practices.
In 2005, when the fish farm companies and environmental organizations wanted to triple the size of the feedlots in the area—effectively tripling the sea lice count—Alex went to attorney Greg McDade for an injunction. But upon reviewing the case, Greg saw that “the whole thing was not lawful” because the fish farms were in the ocean, which falls under federal jurisdiction. Alex and Greg petitioned the B.C. Supreme Court, and the result was a ruling that the provincial government of B.C. could no longer regulate salmon farming and was thereby denied the right to grant expansion of the farm sites.
Alex was happy to have won that battle, but she knew her work wasn’t over. When she attended the salmon farmers’ Annual General Meeting in Norway in 2009, she was disappointed to learn that the industry was bound to continuously expand to meet shareholder demands—no matter the cost to the ecosystem. It was then she realized the fish feedlot industry had to get out of the ocean and into tanks; if not, they would simply expand “until they created a problem so big for themselves that they would be forced to leave or change.” By then, Alex feared, it would be too late to preserve the wild salmon. She likens the situation to being “in an M.C. Escher drawing with one of those staircases. It looks perfectly logical step after step, but pretty soon you end up in a situation that is actually impossible.”
Power to the people
In 2010, Alex moved beyond science and research, and began rallying the people of B.C. and Canada to get behind salmon farm reform. “I’m quite convinced to this day that if enough people stand up and say, ‘We don’t want this in our waters,’ it wouldn’t happen,” she says. She didn’t know what the critical mass was, but she was willing to find out.
Working with a number of local volunteers, as well as the full cooperation of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP), Alex organized a 500km walk from Echo Bay to Victoria to give the public an opportunity to stand up for wild salmon and ask that salmon farming “Get Out” of the ocean. The Get Out Migration started with about 10 people on April 22, 2010, Earth Day; by the time they reached the B.C. Legislature on May 9, Mother’s Day, their numbers had grown to nearly 7,000.
Public reception to the walk was overwhelmingly positive. The group was met with drumming ceremonies and flying doves as they made their way through the First Nations communities. But the media was less responsive. Despite the parliamentary security team confirming their number count at close to 7,000, papers reported that there were “almost 1,000 people” in attendance; in the end, “nothing happened,” says Alex.
Still, it wasn’t for naught. Alex gained the experience of organizing a major protest and the knowledge that there was support from area residents, particularly people in First Nations communities. So she forged on.
In October 2010, Alex and friends organized a seven-day paddle down the lower Fraser River with 100 people in 10 Voyageur canoes. This time, rather than simply stating that they wanted fish farms out of the region, they “put a very fine point on it.” The Cohen Inquiry was getting underway to investigate the decline of sockeye salmon in the Fraser River; Alex and the canoeists planned to arrive in Vancouver on the Inquiry’s opening day to request that all fish farmers be required to submit their disease records.
“The paddle was really an incredible event,” she says. “(As with the walk), I was surrounded by the best of humanity.” It became a largely First Nations event, with Aboriginal communities offering band halls as sleeping areas and welcoming the paddlers with drum ceremonies and full regalia. In spite of the chilly October weather, “everyone was just so deeply happy to be part of something like this.”
When they arrived at the courthouse on a very rainy October 25, Alex and two chiefs entered the building carrying a soaking elk hide full of signatures in support of “releasing the salmon farm disease records to find out if farm diseases were killing the Fraser sockeye.” They stood at the front of the courtroom for 15 minutes, shivering and dripping, until Justice Cohen finally acknowledged them. The three simply nodded silently and left, but they got their message across. Justice Cohen agreed to their request.
In the end, close to one million documents were submitted to the Inquiry on a range of issues. As a participant in the process, Alex has full access to the files and has been diligently reading through them as quickly as she can. Her current goal is to prepare a report for the aquaculture portion of the Cohen Inquiry, which is fast approaching in August 2011. “My hope is that we can change DFO and make it so that the department responds to the biology of the situation, rather than the policy,” she says. It’s a slim hope, she admits, but having the odds stacked against her isn’t something that’s ever stopped her from doing all she can for something she believes in.
There’s no place like home
As Alex moves forward, she’s putting everything on the line to protect the salmon and ecosystem of Echo Bay. All her work is volunteer-based, and she’s supported by contributions from friends. Legal and research costs have been funded through the “thousands of small donations” she’s received at salmonaresacred.org and raincoastresearch.org. She doesn’t see living without a salary as a sustainable solution. But she also doesn’t see that she has a choice.
“If you’re being paid by a large funding organization, you are unfortunately tapped into the corporate world,” she says. “I see every one of (those organizations) turn to negotiating. That can be good in some areas, but when it comes to doing something that’s completely wrong, it’s not good. There is no right way to do the wrong thing.”
With that awareness, Alex continues to lead her own work, gratefully accepting the interest and collaboration of other volunteers when it’s available. There is very little she wouldn’t do to protect the people, animals and wilderness around her. “I deeply, deeply love this place,” she says of Canada’s west coast. “It’s really where I belong. It’s given me a real sense of home, and it’s been incredibly generous to me and I’m trying to be generous back. A lot of people ask what’s behind my motivation; it’s love. When somebody really falls in love with something, it’s one of those things that doesn’t actually need any fuel.”
The other reason Alex will not give up is that she knows it isn’t too late. She admits that we don’t yet see “how far off the cliff we’ve gone.” But while “we’ve boxed ourselves into this,” she says we’ve also developed the science to fix it. “It’s like in The Wizard of Oz. With her slippers, her red, beautiful ruby slippers, Dorothy had the power all along. She went through living hell, but she didn’t know that she just had to click those heels together. I feel like we’re in such a similar place right now. We don’t realize that we as individual human beings on this planet have the power.”
* * *
For more on Alex, ‘Like’ her Facebook page, follow @alex4salmon on Twitter, visit alexandramorton.ca or salmonaresacred.org, check out her blog or email email@example.com. You can further explore her work by reading her book, Listening to Whales.
To follow the Cohen Inquiry, visit cohencommission.ca; the judge’s report is scheduled for release in June 2012.